It’s been a while since I found myself so invested and emotionally affected by a movie as I was by Barron’s Cove. It sometimes feels like the world and entertainment have grown stale, and that maybe being so engrossed in the movie business has blunted my senses. Horror is never scary, comedy is never funny. I yearn for a piece of fiction that will make me feel something, and I got it today with this incredible, riveting, emotionally tormenting crime thriller, courtesy of writer/director Evan Ari Kelman. This movie has actually restored my faith a little. Here is a story that explores the darkest places that grief, rage, and the quest for truth can take everyday people, and how nothing ever happens in a vacuum. There is always a complex web of players in any situation, causing it, feeling its effects, progressing it, or holding it back. Barron’s Cove so meticulously captures the moving parts of a terrible situation, establishing stakes but never revealing its hand too early. This is a truly magnificent piece of cinema.
What is ‘Barron’s Cove’ About?

The movie starts out with a young boy tied to train tracks out in the middle of the woods. Two other boys are there: one desperately trying to untie the kid while the other warns of an approaching train. We cut to Caleb (Garrett Hedlund) carrying out his latest assignment as a heavy for his uncle Benji (Stephen Lang), a local shady businessman who enjoys the perks of his position while sending guys like Caleb out to do the dirty work to keep him there. Caleb is due to spend the weekend with his young son, Barron, but Benji insists that he do one more job for him. When Caleb goes to collect the kid from his mom, Jackie (Brittany Snow), they suddenly, desperately, realize that neither knows where he is, and it is soon revealed that their little boy was the one tied to the tracks.

Related

Collider Debuts Exclusive Looks at the Hottest Summer 2025 Releases, From ‘How to Train Your Dragon’ to ‘Jurassic World Rebirth’

From ‘How to Train Your Dragon’ to ‘Jurassic Word Rebirth,’ you won’t want to miss this week.

The identities of the two other boys at the scene are soon discovered, one of whom is Ethan (Christian Convery), the adopted son of Lyle Chambers (Hamish Linklater), a local politician from a prominent family. The kid won’t tell anyone anything about how Barron was killed and, in fact, seems to revel in holding the information over everybody’s head, so when Caleb can’t get Ethan to tell him what happened, his absolute unbridled rage sees him kidnap the kid from his private school and hold him hostage at a rural lakehouse until the truth comes out. From there, a multi-layered scramble to either help, hinder, or hound Caleb ensues, while he gets closer to knowing Ethan, and what happened to his son.
‘Barron’s Cove’ Pulls No Emotional Punches

The circumstances are established very early on, and within the first fifteen minutes, you feel solid in your stance towards each of the characters. Jackie knows it’s not Caleb’s fault, but she can’t let go of the petty what-ifs that may have avoided her son’s death. Caleb is a man brought to the absolute edge of his sanity, and were he not so driven by revenge, he’d probably just kill himself. Benji wants to help his nephew, but has a hard-earned reputation to uphold. Detective Navarro (Raúl Castillo) is sympathetic to the grieving parents, but knows this situation has to be handled delicately and legally. And then there’s Ethan, whose utter lack of remorse, and constant taunting of a grieving parent, causes any sympathy to evaporate at an incredible rate. When Caleb ties him up in a basement and then goes rummaging through a friend’s dimly-lit tool shed considering axes, hatchets, and other various weapons, you cannot wait to see this little bastard get what’s coming to him. He’s void of humanity, sympathy or regret over causing another child’s death, so screw him. You hope Caleb makes unrecognizable mincemeat out of him. Of course, it would be a little too cathartic for a movie of this sort to lean fully into the kid just being evil, and the adult exacting well-deserved revenge on him. So things start to come out about Ethan and his family background. Despite being chosen by a prominent politician, plucked out of a supposedly abusive home to be rescued by someone richer and better-connected, it seems all is not well at home, and Chambers had his own twisted reasons for adopting in the first place. It quickly dissolves into a meditation on the cycle of abuse and the old cliché of how hurt people, hurt people, particularly when Caleb’s family history is expanded upon. But the movie isn’t so cowardly as to wander into this territory and expect all of Ethan’s actions to somehow be forgiven. He’s no angel, and the fact is that he has caused pain, suffering, and death to another child is not shied away from. Although the movie does get perhaps a little too sympathetic towards him by the final act, it has the balls to stick to its setup.
‘Barron’s Cove’ is Full of Deep Characterization and Fantastic Performances

Image via Well Go USA

This is an incredibly emotional story, full of main characters, secondary characters and bit-players who all feel the fallout of this situation, and what Barron’s Cove does so well is develop these characters to the point that while you feel a particular way about each of them, none of them feels wrong in how they respond to it all. They all have their own perfectly clear motivations, and while there are bad guys and double-crosses, it all makes sense. The movie doesn’t try to pull the rug out from under you for the sake of shock factor; these are just the logical reactions of very well-built characters. Kelman’s writing and direction are sharp as a tack, carried brilliantly by very strong performances across the board. Hedlund turns in a powerhouse performance as Caleb, to the point that it must have been an emotionally and physically exhausting role for him. He throws his whole being into embodying a man so racked with anguish that any sense of control or restraint is long gone. It also can’t have been an easy ride for Convery, who spends a good portion of the runtime being yelled at, threatened, or pushed around by burly adults. The whole cast does their part to immerse the audience in a world where powerful people usually win, those who are wronged never get justice, and the consequences of this whole dreadful ordeal are felt by everybody involved. It puts you through the emotional wringer and gets you so invested that it becomes something of a spectator sport that you can’t help but project your own feelings onto. You hope certain people die horribly, and that others will get their revenge by any means necessary. Barron’s Cove is a hell of a ride, one that grabs you by the throat and doesn’t let go until it’s good and ready. It makes you want to cry, cheer, and despair at the injustice of it all. It appeals to your most basic instincts as an emotionally developed human being, and arouses genuine reactions of disgust, outrage, and sympathy. This isn’t some mindless action hero story about a dark, brooding guy with a laundry list of asses to kick, all while a precocious little kid changes him for the better. It’s a deep, dark delve into tragedy and its many ramifications, and it is absolutely captivating. Barron’s Cove comes to theaters and VOD on June 6.

Barron’s Cove

A razor-sharp, emotionally-devastating crime thriller where the stakes are high, and chances of justice are low.

Release Date

October 6, 2024

Director

Evan Ari Kelman

Writers

Evan Ari Kelman

Producers

Chadd Harbold, Jordan Yale Levine, Shaun S. Sanghani, Jason Michael Berman, Will Raynor, Jordan Beckerman, Cory Thompson

Pros & Cons

The whole cast delivers sterling performances, with Garrett Hedlund stealing the show.
A complex and emotionally-driven story keeps you completely invested from beginning to end.
Evan Ari Kelman’s writing and direction keep a frantic pace of compelling action.

The child antagonist is viewed a little too sympathetically towards the end.